| Player | POS | Award | Team | Season | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| x2 | 7 Noah Cohen | QB | All-Pro | Season 3 | |
| x2 | 13 Isaiah Harris | WR | All-Pro | Season 3 | |
| x2 | 85 Rob Porter | WR | All-Pro | Season 3 | |
| x2 | 36 Stephen Chatman | HB | All-Pro | Season 3 | |
| 32 Daniel Crane | HB | All-Pro | Season 3 | ||
| 28 Julian Foster Retired | TE | All-Pro | Season 3 | ||
| x2 | 95 Joe Bailey | DE | All-Pro | Season 3 | |
| 68 Will Collins | DT | All-Pro | Season 3 | ||
| 29 Xavier Walker | CB | All-Pro | Season 3 | ||
| 47 Connor Henderson | CB | All-Pro | Season 3 | ||
| 43 Clay Moss | S | All-Pro | Season 3 | ||
| x2 | 40 Wayne Williams | TE | All-Pro | Season 3 | |
| x2 | 62 Tyler Bull | DT | All-Pro | Season 3 | |
| 52 Brian Kraus | DE | All-Pro | Season 3 | ||
| 53 Cliff Paige | OLB | All-Pro | Season 3 | ||
| 51 Alexandre Morton | MLB | All-Pro | Season 3 | ||
| 48 Zack McDade | MLB | All-Pro | Season 3 | ||
| 37 Herb Her | OLB | All-Pro | Season 3 | ||
| 23 Rees Ford | S | All-Pro | Season 3 | ||
| x2 | 33 Keith Baker | FB | All-Pro | Season 3 | |
| 8 Russell McDowell | K | All-Pro | Season 3 | ||
| 0 Antonio Stanley | P | All-Pro | Season 3 | ||
| x2 | 56 Brandon Long | T | All-Pro | Season 3 | |
| 61 David Pulley | G | All-Pro | Season 3 | ||
| 72 Chris Simpson | G | All-Pro | Season 3 | ||
| 71 Cornelius Yao | T | All-Pro | Season 3 | ||
| 63 Jeremy Dvorak | C | All-Pro | Season 3 |