| Player | POS | Award | Team | Season | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| x4 | 17 Josh Amukamara | QB | All-Pro | Season 4 | |
| x3 | 1 Ja'Marr Cook | WR | All-Pro | Season 4 | |
| 84 KeAndre Long | WR | All-Pro | Season 4 | ||
| 0 Jahmyr Green | HB | All-Pro | Season 4 | ||
| 7 Bijan Roberts | HB | All-Pro | Season 4 | ||
| x2 | 88 Dawson Kelly | TE | All-Pro | Season 4 | |
| x2 | 89 Mark Adams | TE | All-Pro | Season 4 | |
| x2 | 58 Bobby Orlovsky | MLB | All-Pro | Season 4 | |
| 97 Dexter Latham | DT | All-Pro | Season 4 | ||
| x2 | 23 Kenny Moore | CB | All-Pro | Season 4 | |
| 92 Dallas Gaines | MLB | All-Pro | Season 4 | ||
| 48 Edefuan Uzomah | OLB | All-Pro | Season 4 | ||
| 41 Josaiah Smith | DE | All-Pro | Season 4 | ||
| 94 Mason Goode | DT | All-Pro | Season 4 | ||
| x3 | 27 Caleb Raymond | S | All-Pro | Season 4 | |
| 20 DJ Turbin | CB | All-Pro | Season 4 | ||
| x3 | 45 Tuli Torres | DE | All-Pro | Season 4 | |
| 56 Dion Jenkins | OLB | All-Pro | Season 4 | ||
| 44 Chris Butts | S | All-Pro | Season 4 | ||
| 52 Creed Hill | C | All-Pro | Season 4 | ||
| 33 Tyler Larsen | K | All-Pro | Season 4 | ||
| 5 Cameron Jackson Retired | P | All-Pro | Season 4 | ||
| 65 Lane Jarwin | T | All-Pro | Season 4 | ||
| 27 Chris Marshall | FB | All-Pro | Season 4 | ||
| 65 Trey Schultz | G | All-Pro | Season 4 | ||
| 56 Quenton Nkemdiche | G | All-Pro | Season 4 | ||
| 79 Ikem Enriquez | T | All-Pro | Season 4 |