| Player | POS | Award | Team | Season | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| x4 | 10 Arthur Smith | QB | All-Pro | Season 5 | |
| x3 | 90 T.J. Woodhead Retired | DE | All-Pro | Season 5 | |
| 57 A.J. Easton | DE | All-Pro | Season 5 | ||
| x3 | 91 Tyleik Webster | DT | All-Pro | Season 5 | |
| 86 Efton Chapman | WR | All-Pro | Season 5 | ||
| 12 Nico Cordova | WR | All-Pro | Season 5 | ||
| x4 | 88 Pat Ferentz | TE | All-Pro | Season 5 | |
| 66 Myles Anderson | DT | All-Pro | Season 5 | ||
| 45 Nick Matias | OLB | All-Pro | Season 5 | ||
| 22 Najee Holland | HB | All-Pro | Season 5 | ||
| 19 Brent Zimmer | TE | All-Pro | Season 5 | ||
| 8 Josh Johnson | HB | All-Pro | Season 5 | ||
| 57 LaRoy Demarco | MLB | All-Pro | Season 5 | ||
| x2 | 90 Carson Simon | MLB | All-Pro | Season 5 | |
| 47 Vince Lewis | CB | All-Pro | Season 5 | ||
| 48 Mitchell Hubbard | CB | All-Pro | Season 5 | ||
| 35 Bennie Sanders | S | All-Pro | Season 5 | ||
| 31 Antoine Williams | S | All-Pro | Season 5 | ||
| x2 | 27 Alex Brown | OLB | All-Pro | Season 5 | |
| 70 Rashawn Smallwood | T | All-Pro | Season 5 | ||
| 17 Ryan Fede | K | All-Pro | Season 5 | ||
| 14 Michael Burns | P | All-Pro | Season 5 | ||
| x2 | 69 Anthony Byrd | G | All-Pro | Season 5 | |
| 43 Jakob James Retired | FB | All-Pro | Season 5 | ||
| 78 Terence Sims | T | All-Pro | Season 5 | ||
| x2 x2 | 79 Lloyd Cummings | C | All-Pro | Season 5 | |
| x2 | 66 Jordan Moore | G | All-Pro | Season 5 |